Group tours vs. independent travel: pros and cons

Posted on 6 June 2024 By Nomvelo Masango

Have you started thinking about your next vacation? Often, this includes having to choose the kind of travel arrangement you would like to adopt in order to achieve the desired travel experience.

While group tours provide convenience, peace of mind and the expertise of experienced guides, independent travel offers freedom and flexibility.

In order to help you make an informed decision, here’s a look at the pros and cons of both travel arrangements:

Group tours

Group Travel 2

Credit: Felix Rostig / Unsplash

Group tours mainly entail travelling with an organised group of people. On the trip, you will follow a set itinerary which is normally planned by a travel company.

As part of the group, you will be led by a professional guide and the planning of all travel logistics (such as accommodation, dining arrangements and transportation) is done on your behalf.

The pros of group tours

  1. Convenience: Group tours provide a packaged trip where everything is planned on your behalf. This saves a lot of time and effort as you don’t have to worry about details such as accommodation, transportation and booking itinerary activities.
  2. Structure and peace of mind: An itinerary is planned out for you and all you have to do is follow it. Thus, your travel experience is more structured and less chaotic as you don’t have to worry about what you will be doing each day.
  3. Meeting new people: Group tours come with the opportunity to share social experiences with other group members. This means that you can still have a small community around you to share your travel experiences, even if you aren’t travelling with friends and family.
Group Travel 3

Credit: People Images / iStock

The cons of group tours

  1. Limited freedom and flexibility: In following a set itinerary, there is very little room to deviate from it. This means that you may not be able to see other desired attractions or to attempt other activities.
  2. The quality of the guides can vary: Being part of a group tour comes with an element of placing your travel experience in the hands of a guide. Unfortunately, some guides are more knowledgeable and experienced than others. Those with less enthusiasm and insight can affect the overall quality of your experience.
  3. There’s a downside to travelling with a group of strangers: Travelling and exploring as part of a group means that you receive less individual attention. Thus, your preferences may not always be accommodated. Moreover, you don’t have much control of who is part of your travel group. You may be in for an unpleasant experience if you are in a group with people who are unpleasant travel buddies.

Independent travel

Livingstone is the ideal solo travel destination

Picture: Getaway Gallery

When travelling independently, you get to plan your own trip. You are in charge of all the travel research, as well as the booking of accommodation and flights. Moreover, you are responsible for the planning of your whole itinerary.

The pros of independent travel

  1. Total control of your trip: Travelling independently means that you are in charge of your entire travel experience. You also have the freedom of curating an itinerary which caters to all your personal preferences.
  2. The chance to sharpen planning skills: Planning your own trip can teach you a lot, thus making you a better and more informed planner for any of your upcoming trips.
  3. An increased chance of connecting with locals: When travelling independently, you do not have a knowledgeable guide to rely on. As such, this is the chance to connect to locals as you receive their assistance with things such as directions and recommended dining spots. Connecting with locals is advantageous and can give you a better understanding of your destination’s culture and way of life.

Picture: Holly Amanda rich / Unsplash

The cons of independent travel

  1. More time and effort required: Being responsible for planning all aspects of your trip will require more time and effort.
  2. You may feel isolated and sometimes unsafe: Since you are not exploring as part of a group, a lack of community may result in loneliness.  Sometimes, being alone can also result in feeling unsafe in higher risk areas.
  3. You may end up paying more: When travelling independently, you forfeit the opportunity of receiving any group discounts. Often, solo rates are slightly more expensive.

Ultimately, choosing between group tours and independent travel should be an informed decision. It is important to weigh out the pros and cons of each travel arrangement. This will help you see which option is more aligned with your budget,  travel preferences and desired experience.

Follow us on social media for more travel news, inspiration, and guides. You can also tag us to be featured. 

TikTok | Instagram Facebook Twitter

ALSO READ: Best Milkshake Spots in Johannesburg

yoast-primary - 1004429
tcat - Travel ideas
tcat_slug - travel-ideas
tcat2 - Travel ideas
tcat2_slug - travel-ideas
tcat_final - travel